The evidence
Why a classroom in a bag works. Every number sourced.
For NGOs, foundations, governments and development partners: what the research says about structured lessons, why hardware alone has failed, and how each part of an EAP lesson maps to a body of evidence.
The scale of the need
350 million children and youth, aged 6 to 18.
Across sub-Saharan Africa, about 350 million children and youth have no access to interactive lessons. That includes 98 million who are out of school entirely.
- ≈250M
- learners enrolled in school across sub-Saharan Africa with no interactive lessons: about 9 in 10 of the 278 million enrolled (EAP estimate)20
- 98M
- children and youth aged 6 to 18 in sub-Saharan Africa who are out of school entirely1
- ≈350M
- children and youth aged roughly 6 to 18 who could be reached
How we get there: 278 million learners are enrolled in primary and secondary school across sub-Saharan Africa.20 We estimate that about 9 in 10 of them have no interactive lessons, which gives about 250 million. Add UNESCO’s 98 million out of school1 and the total is about 350 million.
The problem in Kenya
Half of Kenya’s public-school Grade 6 learners cannot read the English every other subject is taught in.
- 11.9M
- learners in Kenya’s primary and junior schools, Grades 1 to 9, in 2025.19
- 79%
- of Kenyan children are in learning poverty: unable to read and understand an age-appropriate text by late primary.2
- 51%
- of public-school Grade 6 learners cannot read and understand a Grade 3 English passage. English is the language every other subject is taught in.3
- 72,000
- junior-school teacher shortfall, within a national shortage of 96,345. Teachers cover learning areas they were never trained in.4
- 1 : 46
- public primary pupil-to-teacher ratio. 54% of observed classrooms hold more than 45 learners, and 11% hold more than 90.5
- 98%
- of observed classrooms had no internet. Government devices reached 99.6% of primary schools, but usage stayed below 40%.6
For comparison, teachers across OECD countries spend about 6.5 hours a week planning lessons.7 Kenya was not part of that survey. A junior-school teacher handed subjects they were never trained in needs more.
The expert panel’s verdict
Hardware alone is a Bad Buy. Structured pedagogy is a Great Buy.
The Global Education Evidence Advisory Panel, convened by the World Bank, FCDO, UNICEF and USAID, ranks what works per dollar.8,9
Great Buy
Structured pedagogy
Ready-made lesson plans, matching teaching materials and ongoing teacher support, delivered as one package.
≈ 3 years
of quality-adjusted schooling gained per $100 spent on structured lesson plans, in the World Bank analysis behind the panel’s ratings.9 The panel cites Kenya’s Tusome among its examples.
Bad Buy
Hardware on its own
Laptops, tablets, projectors or smartboards shipped without lessons, materials and support.
≈ 0 years
gained per $100. Computers added without software and teacher training had no effect on learning in Peru and Colombia, and a negative one in Israel and Costa Rica.8
Where the ClassKit sits
All three parts, in one bag
- Lesson plans: 11,000+ CBE-aligned lessons, every strand and sub-strand.
- Materials: about 40,000 images and videos on a shared screen, offline.
- Teacher support: an offline teacher app with five-minute preparation for every lesson. Training videos and termly coaching visits are planned.
The projector is the delivery vehicle, not the product.
Proven in Kenya
Pre-planned, standardised lessons have produced some of the largest learning gains ever measured in Africa.
Tusome · national programme
0.6 – 1.0 SD
gains in English and Kiswahili reading across all public primary schools. Grade 2 English gains roughly equalled an extra full year of schooling.10
Every 10 structured lessons a teacher covered added one more correct word per minute to pupils’ reading. Coverage drove learning.
Bridge · randomised trial
+0.81 SD
for primary pupils after two years of centrally written lesson guides, equal to 0.89 extra years of schooling. The effect is in the 99th percentile of at-scale programmes.11
Scholarships were awarded by lottery. The weakest pupils gained most, and girls and boys gained equally.
SD means standard deviation, the unit education trials use. An effect of 0.2 to 0.3 SD is a solid programme result. An effect of 0.8 SD is among the largest ever recorded.
Proven in this format
Curriculum videos, two deliveries. On a shared screen led by the teacher, pupils gained. On their own tablets, pupils lost.
Classroom screen · the ClassKit model
+0.3 SD
in maths and science after four months: about 60% more learning than the control group. Pupils were 5 points more likely to pass the government exam, and teacher and pupil attendance rose.12
One tablet per pupil
−0.4 SD
on similar curriculum content loaded onto personal tablets with no classroom screen. Pupils learned less than with no technology at all.12
The trial
- Government middle schools in Punjab, Pakistan, 2016–17.
- Classroom arm: 59 schools and 2,999 Grade 8 pupils. Tablet arm: 71 schools and 3,614 Grade 6 pupils. The two arms ran in different schools and grades, so they are not a head-to-head comparison.
- Short videos mapped chapter by chapter to the official curriculum, with review questions after each.
- Teachers previewed each video before class, then showed it on a large screen: the same prepare-then-project loop as EAP’s teacher app.
- Two days of training. 95% of teachers used it at least twice a week.
A trial of teacher-led, projected instruction in rural Ghana found a similar result: +0.23 SD in maths.13
Inside every lesson
Each part of an EAP lesson maps to a body of research.
| What every lesson has | Strongest study | Headline finding |
|---|---|---|
| The same structure every lesson: objective, vocabulary, content, check, activity, close | Tusome, Kenya10 | 0.6 to 1.0 SD. One more correct word per minute for every 10 structured lessons covered. |
| Images and video on a shared screen | Mayer’s multimedia principle; Pakistan eLearn trial14,12 | Learners did better from words and pictures than words alone in 13 of 13 experiments. +0.3 SD when projected and teacher-led. |
| Two vocabulary words per slide, with a definition and a Kenyan example | Stahl and Fairbanks meta-analysis15 | Up to 0.97 SD on comprehension of taught words. Definition plus context works best. |
| A check question on every slide | Adesope et al.: 272 effect sizes, 15,427 participants16 | Practice testing g = 0.61. Feedback is worth about six months’ progress. |
| A learning activity | Freeman et al.: 225 studies17 | +0.47 SD. Pupils taught by lecture alone were 1.5 times as likely to fail. |
| A closing question | Roediger and Karpicke18 | 61% recalled after a week with retrieval practice, against 40% with re-reading. |
| Preloaded and offline, one kit per class | Kenya Digital Literacy Programme evaluations6 | Devices reached 99.6% of schools but were used in under 40%. 98% of classrooms are offline. |
Lab and university effect sizes run larger than classroom effects in low-income settings. We quote them as design evidence, not forecasts.
Our commitment
No independent study has evaluated EAP yet. This is how we will produce the first number, within one school year.
- 01
Baseline and endline tests
A 10-minute oral reading fluency check (words per minute, the Tusome measure) and a numeracy check for every class, at launch and at the end of the school year.
- 02
Usage logs on every kit
Lessons opened and time per slide, giving the same dose-response data Tusome had.
- 03
Teacher time survey
Planning hours per week, subjects taught outside training and confidence, at baseline and endline.
- 04
Teacher app usage
Preparation opened before each lesson. With funding, training videos watched and one coaching visit per term.
- 05
Independent evaluator
With funding: a matched comparison across 20 to 40 schools over one academic year, run by a Kenyan research partner, with outcomes pre-registered in standard deviations.
- 06
Foundations reading strand (planned)
Planned: Grade 3-level English reading with audio inside junior-school lessons: teaching at the right level, the panel’s other Great Buy.
Our target is about 0.3 SD, which would place the ClassKit alongside the most cost-effective programmes the expert panel has reviewed. Funders and research partners can help design the evaluation with us.
Sources
Where every number comes from.
- UNESCO Institute for Statistics, “244M children won’t start the new school year”, September 2022. Sub-Saharan Africa: 98 million out of school, ages 6 to 18. Read it
- World Bank and UNESCO Institute for Statistics, Learning Poverty brief for Kenya, 2024 (74% of Grade 6 below minimum English reading proficiency in AMPL-b 2023, adjusted for out-of-school children). Read it
- Usawa Agenda, Foundational Literacy and Numeracy Assessment (FLANA), 2025: 51.3% of public primary Grade 6 learners, as reported by the Daily Nation. Read it
- Teachers Service Commission figures, as reported by the Daily Nation, 2025–26. Read it
- Parliament of Kenya, Senate report on pupil-to-teacher ratios; Edu-Design classroom observation study, 2023.
- Edu-Design, 2023; University of Notre Dame Pulte Institute, “Digital Learning in Kenya”, on Kenya’s Digital Literacy Programme, 2024. Read it
- OECD, Teaching and Learning International Survey (TALIS), 2018. An average across OECD countries; Kenya did not take part. Read it
- Global Education Evidence Advisory Panel (World Bank, FCDO, UNICEF, USAID), “Cost-effective approaches to improve global learning”, 2023. Read it
- Angrist, Evans, Filmer, Glennerster, Rogers and Sabarwal, “How to Improve Education Outcomes Most Efficiently?”, World Bank Policy Research Working Paper 9450, 2020. Read it
- Piper, Destefano, Kinyanjui and Ong’ele, “Scaling up successfully: Lessons from Kenya’s Tusome national literacy program”, Journal of Educational Change, 2018. NORC endline evaluation for USAID. Read it
- Gray-Lobe, Keats, Kremer, Mbiti and Ozier, “Can Education Be Standardized? Evidence from Kenya”, Becker Friedman Institute Working Paper 2022-68. Read it
- Beg, Halim, Lucas and Saif, “Engaging Teachers with Technology Increased Achievement, Bypassing Teachers Did Not”, American Economic Journal: Economic Policy 14(2), 2022. Read it
- Johnston and Ksoll, “Effectiveness of interactive satellite-transmitted instruction: Experimental evidence from Ghanaian primary schools”, Economics of Education Review 91, 2022. Read it
- Mayer, Multimedia Learning, 3rd edition, Cambridge University Press, 2020. The multimedia principle: 13 of 13 experiments. Read it
- Stahl and Fairbanks, “The Effects of Vocabulary Instruction: A Model-Based Meta-Analysis”, Review of Educational Research, 1986. Read it
- Adesope, Trevisan and Sundararajan, “Rethinking the Use of Tests: A Meta-Analysis of Practice Testing”, Review of Educational Research, 2017. Education Endowment Foundation Toolkit, feedback. Read it
- Freeman et al., “Active learning increases student performance in science, engineering, and mathematics”, PNAS, 2014. Read it
- Roediger and Karpicke, “Test-Enhanced Learning”, Psychological Science, 2006. Read it
- Kenya National Bureau of Statistics, Economic Survey 2026: 11,935,700 learners in primary and junior school (Grades 1 to 9) in 2025, as reported by People Daily. Read it
- UNESCO Institute for Statistics, via World Bank data: sub-Saharan Africa enrolment, 2024. Primary 196.8 million, secondary 81.4 million. Read it
Bring structured lessons to the schools you support.
Get our partner pack, or see a ClassKit in a classroom.
